Guides · · updated
What a broker opinion of value actually looks at
A broker opinion of value estimates what a space will trade or lease for, built from closed comparables, adjustments for floor, frontage and build-out, concessions turned into net effective rent, and the lease structure. It is faster and cheaper than an appraisal, but it is not an appraisal and a lender will not rely on it.
An owner calls and asks what their space is worth. The honest answer takes a few days, because the number is only as good as the comparables behind it.
A broker opinion of value is not an appraisal. An appraiser is licensed separately, follows a prescribed standard, and produces a document a lender will rely on. A broker opinion is what a broker who works that submarket thinks the space will actually trade or lease for, based on what has recently traded or leased nearby. It costs less, arrives faster, and is the right tool for a decision rather than a loan.
What goes into it
Closed comparables first, asking rents second. What a landlord is asking tells you what they hope for; what a tenant signed tells you what the market paid. The gap between those two numbers is usually the most informative thing on the page.
Then the adjustments. Ground floor is not second floor. A corner with two frontages is not a mid-block door. Twelve-foot ceilings and a grease trap already in place are worth real money to the right tenant and nothing to the wrong one. Every comparable needs moving toward the subject property on each of those axes, and each move needs a reason.
Then the concessions, which is where most quoted rents stop being true. A lease at $50 per square foot with six months free and a $40 per square foot improvement allowance is not a $50 lease. Net effective rent — what the landlord actually collects across the term, after the free months and the money spent getting the tenant in — is the only figure worth comparing.
Then the structure. Who pays taxes, insurance and maintenance changes the number more than most owners expect. A triple-net rent and a gross rent are different units of measurement.
What it cannot tell you
It cannot tell you what a specific buyer will pay, because a buyer with a strategic reason to want your corner will pay more than the market. It cannot predict a lease-up timeline with confidence in a thin submarket where three comparables took eighteen months each. And it is a view on a date, not a standing valuation — in a moving market, a six-month-old opinion is a historical document.
What it is good for: deciding whether to hold, whether to lease now or wait for a better covenant, what to ask, and what to accept. That is usually the decision in front of the owner, and it rarely needs an appraisal to answer.
Questions I get asked
Is a broker opinion of value the same as an appraisal?
No. An appraiser is licensed separately, follows a prescribed standard and produces a document a lender will rely on. A broker opinion of value is what a broker who works that submarket thinks the space will actually trade or lease for, based on recent nearby deals. It costs less, arrives faster, and is the right tool for a decision rather than a loan.
Why are closed comparables weighted above asking rents?
An asking rent is what a landlord hopes for; a signed lease is what the market paid. The gap between the two is often the most informative number on the page, so the opinion starts from closed deals and treats asking figures as a ceiling to test rather than a value.
What is net effective rent and why does it matter?
It is what the landlord actually collects across the term after the free months and the improvement allowance spent getting the tenant in. A lease at $50 per square foot with six months free and a $40 per square foot allowance is not a $50 lease, so net effective rent is the only figure worth comparing.
What can an opinion of value not tell me?
It cannot say what a specific buyer with a strategic reason will pay, it cannot predict lease-up time with confidence in a thin submarket, and it is a view on a date. In a moving market a six-month-old opinion is a historical document, so ask for a refresh before you act on it.